Are We Buying Skincare That Works, or Are We Just Buying a Name?

CeCe's Beauty Bar
Nov 09, 2026By CeCe's Beauty Bar

Let's talk about something that has been on my mind lately.

If I had to choose between buying a moisturizer from an established skincare brand that has spent years researching, formulating, and developing products, or buying a moisturizer from an influencer who has recently launched their own skincare line, I would personally lean toward the established skincare brand.

Now, before anyone misunderstands what I'm saying, let me explain.

This is not me saying that every influencer-created brand is bad. It is not me saying that celebrities and influencers cannot create good skincare products. And it certainly isn't me saying that a product automatically becomes better simply because it comes from a well-known skincare company.

That is not the point of this conversation.

The point is that we need to stop confusing popularity with expertise, and marketing with formulation.

Somewhere along the way, we started treating a familiar face as a reason to trust a product. We see someone we follow launch a moisturizer, serum, toner, or cleanser, and suddenly we feel as though they must know exactly what our skin needs.

But do they?

And more importantly, what are we actually basing that trust on?

When did the name on the bottle become more important than what is inside it?

We live in a world where an influencer can announce a new skincare launch, and within hours, products can sell out. People rush to purchase the newest moisturizer or serum because someone they follow has told them it is amazing.

We see the packaging, the beautiful campaign, the flawless skin, and the excitement surrounding the launch. We hear about the product's benefits, watch it being applied, and see hundreds of comments from people who cannot wait to get their hands on it.

And I understand it. Marketing is powerful.

When we follow someone for years, we can begin to feel connected to them. We watch their routines, listen to their recommendations, and become familiar with their preferences. Eventually, that familiarity can translate into trust.

So when they tell us they have created the perfect moisturizer, we want to believe them.

But I want you to stop for a moment and ask yourself a question.

Are you buying that moisturizer because you understand the formulation and believe it is right for your skin, or are you buying it because you recognize the person whose name is on the bottle?

Those are two very different reasons to purchase a product.

And I think we need to become more comfortable acknowledging the difference.

Being the face of a product is not the same as formulating it

Here is where I think the conversation becomes important.

When an influencer launches a skincare brand, their involvement can vary significantly. Some are deeply involved in product development, work closely with cosmetic chemists, participate in testing, and spend considerable time refining their formulas. Others may contribute primarily through branding, marketing, packaging, and creative direction.

There is nothing inherently wrong with either business model. A founder does not necessarily need to be a cosmetic chemist to create a successful skincare company.

But we, as consumers, need to understand that distinction.

The person whose name appears on a product is not necessarily the person who developed its formula. They may not be the person who selected the ingredients, determined the concentrations, conducted stability testing, or evaluated how the product performs over time.

Those responsibilities may belong to cosmetic chemists, formulation laboratories, product developers, safety professionals, and manufacturing teams.

And those people deserve recognition, too.

I want to know who is doing the work behind the scenes. I want to know whether the brand has invested in thoughtful formulation, appropriate testing, and quality control. I want to understand what makes the product worth purchasing beyond the fact that someone famous is attached to it.

Because putting your name on a bottle and developing a product that performs well are not the same thing.

A name can introduce me to a product. It should not be the only reason I trust it.

Selling out does not automatically mean a product is exceptional

One of the biggest things we need to remember is that a product selling out does not necessarily tell us how well it works.

It tells us that people wanted to buy it.

And there are many reasons why that might happen.

The founder may have a loyal audience. The campaign may be beautifully executed. The packaging may be appealing. The product may be connected to a viral trend, or the launch may create a sense of urgency that makes people feel they need to purchase it before it disappears.

Of course, the product might also be genuinely excellent. A popular product can absolutely be a good product.

But popularity alone cannot tell us whether a moisturizer will support our skin barrier, whether a serum will suit our skin type, or whether a particular formula will irritate someone who has sensitive skin.

A sellout does not tell us how a product performs after four weeks of consistent use. It does not tell us whether it works well for dry skin, oily skin, acne-prone skin, or skin that is easily irritated.

And it certainly does not tell us whether it is appropriate for every person buying it.

We have to stop treating demand as proof of performance.

A product can be popular and still not be right for you.

A product can have simple packaging, very little hype, and no celebrity founder, yet be exactly what your skin needs.

Sometimes, the product that deserves your attention is not the one everyone is talking about. It is the one that makes sense for your individual skin concerns.

Your favorite influencer's skin is not your skin

This is another part of the conversation that I really want people to understand.

Even if an influencer genuinely loves a product, that does not mean you will love it, too.

Their skin may be completely different from yours. They may have a different skin type, different concerns, different sensitivities, and a different routine.

They may also be using other products, receiving professional treatments, working with an esthetician or dermatologist, or following a routine that you do not see in their content.

You are seeing a piece of their skincare experience, not necessarily the entire picture.

For example, if an influencer with oily skin tells you that a particular moisturizer is perfect, that does not automatically mean it will be the best moisturizer for someone with dry, sensitive skin.

Likewise, if a product makes someone's skin look beautifully hydrated in a video, that visual result does not tell you everything about how the formula will behave on your skin over time.

This is why I will always encourage you to understand your own skin before jumping into someone else's routine.

What works for them might work for you. It might not.

And neither outcome means that the product is necessarily good or bad. It means that skincare is personal.

Your skin should be the starting point of your skincare decisions, not somebody else's popularity.

I want to know what is behind the formula

When I think about purchasing skincare, I want to look beyond the marketing campaign.

I want to understand the product itself.

What is the moisturizer designed to do? Is it intended to hydrate, soften, reduce moisture loss, or support the skin barrier? What ingredients help it achieve those goals? Is the formulation appropriate for my skin concerns? Has the brand taken the necessary steps to evaluate the product's safety, stability, and quality?

I do not expect every consumer to become a cosmetic chemist. You should not need a chemistry degree to purchase a moisturizer.

But I do believe brands should make it easier for consumers to understand what they are buying.

I appreciate transparency. I appreciate when a company explains why a product was formulated a certain way, who it is intended for, and what consumers can reasonably expect from it.

I want to see thoughtful product development rather than a campaign that relies entirely on the founder's popularity.

And I want to make it clear that an established skincare brand is not automatically more trustworthy just because it has been around longer. A company can have years of experience and still release a product that is not right for you.

The same questions should apply to every brand, whether it belongs to a celebrity, an influencer, an independent founder, or a company that has been developing skincare for decades.

The difference is that I want my purchasing decision to be based on evidence, formulation, transparency, and suitability rather than recognition alone.

Marketing can make us feel like we need something we never needed before

Have you ever noticed how quickly your skincare routine can start to feel incomplete?

One week, everyone is talking about a new toner. The next week, it is an essence. Then a serum comes along that promises to transform your skin, followed by another moisturizer that supposedly does something your current moisturizer cannot.

Suddenly, the routine you were perfectly happy with feels outdated.

You begin to wonder whether your skin could look better if you just purchased one more product.

And that is where I think we need to pause.

There is nothing wrong with trying new products. There is nothing wrong with enjoying skincare or investing in products that help you feel good about yourself.

But we need to recognize when we are purchasing something because it addresses a genuine concern and when we are purchasing it because marketing has convinced us that we are missing out.

You do not need every product that goes viral.

You do not need to replace your entire routine every time a new brand launches.

And you do not need to spend money on a product simply because someone with beautiful skin tells you it is a must-have.

Sometimes, your skin does not need another serum. It needs consistency. It needs a moisturizer that works well for you. It needs you to stop introducing five new products at once so you can actually understand what your skin responds to.

A good skincare routine does not have to be complicated to be effective.

And the most expensive or most talked-about product is not automatically the best choice.

As a makeup artist, I look at skincare a little differently

My relationship with skincare is closely connected to my work as a makeup artist.

I have always believed that beautiful makeup starts with understanding the skin underneath it. My approach has never been about covering everything up or convincing someone that they need more makeup to look beautiful.

I love skin that looks like skin. I love a healthy-looking glow, thoughtful preparation, and makeup that enhances the person rather than hiding them.

But that kind of result begins long before foundation touches the face.

It begins with understanding the skin and preparing it appropriately.

When skin is dry, dehydrated, irritated, or not responding well to a routine, the way makeup sits on the surface can change. Foundation may emphasize dry patches, cling to texture, or become difficult to blend.

That does not mean every skin concern can be solved with skincare, nor does it mean that a particular moisturizer will magically create perfect skin. Skin texture is normal, and makeup should not be about eliminating every natural feature.

It means that choosing appropriate products and preparing the skin thoughtfully can make a difference.

This is one reason I care so much about understanding what I am putting on the skin, both in my personal routine and when considering products for makeup preparation.

I do not want to use something simply because it is trending. I want to understand its purpose and whether it makes sense for the person sitting in my chair.

And I want my clients to feel empowered to ask those same questions.

You should not feel pressured to purchase a product just because it is popular among makeup artists, influencers, or brides. You should feel comfortable asking whether it is appropriate for your skin, whether you actually need it, and whether there is a simpler alternative.

That is what a skin-first approach means to me.

It is not about having the most products. It is about making thoughtful choices.

So, would I buy from an influencer-created skincare brand?

Yes, I would consider it.

But I would not purchase it simply because I like the influencer.

I would want to know more about the brand, how the products are developed, and whether the formula suits my needs. I would look at the ingredient list, the product's intended purpose, and the information the company provides about its formulation and testing.

I would ask the same questions of a well-established skincare company.

I am not interested in automatically dismissing a product because an influencer created the brand. There are founders who take product development seriously, collaborate with qualified professionals, and create products that deserve consideration.

But I am also not interested in giving a product an automatic pass because its founder has millions of followers.

Being knowledgeable about beauty, having a large audience, and developing a skincare formula are different things. They can overlap, but one does not automatically guarantee the others.

I want to see substance behind the name.

And if a product genuinely offers something that works for my skin, then I am open to it.

But if I am choosing between two moisturizers, I want the decision to come down to which one is better suited to my skin, not which founder I recognize.

Before you buy your next skincare product, ask yourself these questions

The next time you see a skincare product going viral, I want you to take a moment before adding it to your cart.

Ask yourself:

1. What does this product actually do?

Look beyond words like glow, glass skin, and radiance. What is the product intended to help with, and does that match your actual skin concerns?

2. Who developed the formula?

You do not need the founder to be a cosmetic chemist. But it is reasonable to look for transparency about the professionals and processes involved in product development.

3. Is the product appropriate for my skin?

Consider your skin type, sensitivities, current routine, and specific concerns. A product can be well formulated and still not be the right fit for you.

4. Am I buying it because I need it or because it is trending?

There is a difference between wanting to try something for enjoyment and feeling as though you need it to achieve a certain look.

5. What information does the brand provide?

Look for a clear ingredient list, realistic claims, directions for use, and information about product quality and testing. Be cautious of promises that sound too good to be true.

6. Do I trust the product, or do I simply trust the person selling it?

This may be the most important question of all.

You can appreciate a creator's content without purchasing every product they launch. You can admire someone's skin without assuming their routine will work for you.

And you can enjoy beauty trends without allowing them to dictate every decision you make about your skin.

The bottom line: I want to buy a product, not a name

At the end of the day, I want to purchase skincare because I believe the product has a purpose in my routine.

I want to know why I am using it, what it is intended to do, and whether it is appropriate for my skin.

I want to support companies that take formulation, quality, and transparency seriously. I want to appreciate the people who do the behind-the-scenes work to develop products, even when they are not the faces featured in the advertising campaigns.

And I want to see consumers become more confident in their decisions rather than feeling pressured to follow every new launch.

Because your skin does not know who the founder is.

Your skin does not know how many followers a brand has, how quickly a product sold out, or how beautiful the campaign looked.

What matters is the formulation, how you use the product, how your skin responds to it, and whether it meets your needs.

So the next time you see a moisturizer selling out because an influencer launched it, I am not telling you to avoid it.

I am asking you to look a little closer.

Do your research. Read the ingredient list. Understand what the product is designed to do. Consider whether it fits your skin and your budget. And remember that a familiar name is not a substitute for a thoughtful purchasing decision.

You do not have to buy everything someone recommends to take care of yourself.

You do not have to chase every new trend to have a good skincare routine.

And you certainly do not have to buy a product simply because everyone else is buying it.

I would rather invest in a product because I understand why it belongs in my routine than buy it because I recognize the name on the bottle.

That is the difference between buying into the hype and making an informed decision for your skin.

And here at Under Your Skin Mondays, that is the conversation I want us to keep having.

Because skincare should be about understanding your skin, not just following the name everyone is talking about.

As always,

With love,

Cece | Cece's Beauty Bar

Skin first. Always.